Why does every thread here devolve into a "Real" vs. "Replica" argument?

[Dimis]

Originally Posted by REAL 1

While it is hard to explain the distinction between original and Continuation while behind the wheel while the car is in motion to other motorists who are behind me...

Kindly, and if I may humbly point out - It really isn't.
A simple "NO" dispels any questions or illusions to the question "Is it real?"
While a "factual" response, would have everyone answering "YES it is!" as in, well you're NOT imagining it... the "truth" is, it aint real.

So lets just get real, and please, don't muddle the TRUTH with your silly facts...

Originally Posted by REAL 1

which is a genuine '65 427 SO.

Because now when you "claim" your engine to be "genuine" I find it hard to believe... even if you say its "FACT", because I know how you've potentially mislead those before me on your quest to define your car.

Originally Posted by REAL 1

I am proud of the Continuation series moniker and have no need to pretend it is an original. I love my car.

...and truly, that's all that matters! I'm truly happy for you!

Originally Posted by REAL 1

your plate moniker in fact totally misleads them as to what your car in fact is. Your plate moniker could clearly be argued as far more objectionable

Except for one SMALL thing - NO-ONE ESLE is trying to pass there's off as the TRUE thing!

Originally Posted by REAL 1

I'm afraid than my plate moniker which is truthful and accurate and merely requires a simple clarification when asked.

Evan - problem is, even you'd agree "you don't know, what you don't know" and Joe public ie: 99.9% are unaware of the cobra landscape. How would they know it "needs" further clarification?


So in conclusion - the truth is you own a Cobra by Shelby, BUT NO - IT aint any more real than mine or the next guys...

Enjoy your beast!

[Paul F]

Originally Posted by REAL 1

While my plate moniker may confuse other motorists as what generation my Shelby belongs to, your plate moniker in fact totally misleads them as to what your car in fact is. Your plate moniker could clearly be argued as far more objectionable I'm afraid than my plate moniker which is truthful and accurate and merely requires a simple clarification when asked. Your assertion is kind of like the pot calling the kettle black except in this case the kettle isn't black but the pot is. But, alas I agree, its all in fun so no real harm no real foul. Just make a simple observation.

Kind Evan,

I'm sorry to have misled you. I was having a guffaw with you that having badges with the name Shelby are easy to acquire. I should have had the decency to have put a laugh emoticon to indicate the ruse. Regarding the plate, I meant the manufacturing plate, not the license plate.

I don't have a vanity plate nor do I have a badge with the word Shelby on it. That would be a deception that would not reflect well on me. I have a common issue plate.

Wishing you a pleasant night,
Paul F

[RodKnock]

Originally Posted by REAL 1

Paul: Your consideration and acknowledgment is most appreciated. Thank you for acknowledging my car is indeed a 100% genuine Shelby Cobra.

It's definitely very "Cobra-like."

[Joe's Garage]

The registry is only following what Carroll Shebly has already said regarding his replica's -

"Mr. Shelby identified the replicas of the Cobra 427
S/C with the designation CSX 4000.
Shelby has sold the Cobra replica kits for $50,000 to
$150,000."
Testimony from the Judge Walsh Ruling on Trade Dress

We're good here, carry on good peeps.

[trularin]

Timex - takes a licking and keeps on ticking.

[Joe's Garage]

Originally Posted by REAL 1

...
Important part is to respect others and what they own and promote the hobby and the Cobra as it is in jeopardy of being lost to future generations based on waning interest of the upcoming generations.

Maybe you are S L O W L Y coming around. There is no "wheat" or "chaff" with any of these 2nd gen replicas. Just pick a recognized supplier and you'll get a good one.

If you mean it you'll apologize for making such an insulting comment to all the non-CSX owners earlier, you denigrated them more than once on that. No, I don't mean you trying to minimize what you said by suggesting others may think a continuation is chaff based on their criteria, that's just a back peddle cop-out. A sincere apology.

[Joe's Garage]

I'll beat Jamo to the punch.

Romain Jerome Titanic DNA Tourbillon, $319,000 retail



From what I've read it's not even water proof!

[Jamo]

Originally Posted by Joe's Garage

I'll beat Jamo to the punch.

Romain Jerome Titanic DNA Tourbillon, $319,000 retail



From what I've read it's not even water proof!

Damn! Well, I guess for that kind of money, it had beTter make a splash.

[buddyg]

99.9% of the public will see the plate Real1 and think it's an original Cobra. Real and Original are the same to them.

[jhv48]

Originally Posted by buddyg

99.9% of the public will see the plate Real1 and think it's an original Cobra. Real and Original are the same to them.

See, ALMOSTREAL1, he said it in just one sentence. It really is just that simple.
Well, to the rest of us it is.

[Joe's Garage]

Originally Posted by REAL 1

... Important part is to respect others and what they own and promote the hobby and the Cobra as it is in jeopardy of being lost to future generations based on waning interest of the upcoming generations.

There is no "wheat" or "chaff" with any of these 2nd gen replicas. Just pick a recognized supplier and you'll get a good one.

Now apologize to all you have insulted because they don't own a CSX replica like you.


... waiting.

[Blue66]

Originally Posted by Joe's Garage

Now apologize to all you have insulted because they don't own a CSX replica like you..

Why the hell would he ? Some can't afford them OR just don't care. What's the big deal ??? You guys have to get out of your mother's basement . There is a different world out there. Taking this junk way to serious . Ok my car is faster than everyone here

OK have to get a thread going about how old people are here

[Joe's Garage]

Well that puts me in a pickle, what does an organ-grinder do if he loses his dancing monkey?

[trularin]

Originally Posted by Joe's Garage

Well that puts me in a pickle, what does an organ-grinder do if he loses his dancing monkey?

Well done.

[jhv48]

Originally Posted by Joe's Garage

Well that puts me in a pickle, what does an organ-grinder do if he loses his dancing monkey?

Play a different tune!

He'll be back! He can't resist.

That's why it's so easy.

[Joe's Garage]

Yep, maybe add some fruit with the bananas? He can't take the GPS collar off so I'll always know where to find him

[Al G]

I really wonder if some of you guys are a**holes all the time or only on this forum.. Try taking it down a notch.

[RodKnock]

Originally Posted by Al G

I really wonder if some of you guys are a**holes all the time or only on this forum.. Try taking it down a notch.

Those who live in glass houses shouldn't cast stones.

Seriously, your personal attack is unnecessary. Why can't I and others express their opinions on a topic in public forum in a constructive way?

We discussed issues such as the SAAC Registry and its meaning(s), the AC and Shelby history and replica values of both the Kirkhams and Shelbys among other topics.

Why must you insult people? If you don't like this topic, then just ignore it and read another thread.

[Joe's Garage]

Close, you are confusing "some" with one, and he has left for reasons obvious to all.

[Al G]

Originally Posted by Joe's Garage

Close, you are confusing "some" with one, and he has left for reasons obvious to all.

No, he's the one I wasn't including.