As the keeper of the Icon Treasure Chest, I can settle this part of the discussion.
There is no need for us "geek-types" to spend an ounce of time creating a "badge of dishonor" for those that are repeat offenders.
You see, a repeat offender will be shown the door for good, thus no profile will remain to display any padlocks or other garnish.
aaar-aaar.
(oh.... and "oooooo-gah")
(note - check spelling)