Grundy Insurance

[Blue66]

Prices are all over the place. Prob goin to change mine in July for unlimited miles. Keep the updates goin !!

[allcarfan]

Originally Posted by jolsen42

Try Robbin at Mid West classics. I believe they insure more Cobra replicas than anyone else.
Midwest Classic Insurance

John O

This is who I use. Robbin is a good guy.

$80,000 insured value
Limited to 6000 miles per year
No one under 26 can drive the car
Can drive the car to work up to 60 times per year

$740/yr....in Atlanta, where I am sure rates are a little higher.

[1SwtRide]

Originally Posted by tims210

Now i'm really jealous. Called Berkley and they won't insure Montana LLC's nor New Jersey cars. Just a heads up for others.

Digging up an old thread -

Tim (and any other NJ owners),

Did you ever find your solution to insuring your Montana LLC / NJ owned Cobra (e.g., Midwest Classics)?

I'm starting the build process for a Vintage Motorsports Backdraft Racing Cobra. I live in NJ as well. Jay from VMS filled me in on the NJ registration issue so I'm starting the Montana LLC process. Next up will be insurance and Jay recommended Midwest Classics.

I'd like to hear how any of you solved the insurance mystery.

Much appreciated!

John

[brettco]

Name businesses you know of that get to determine the profit margin they want and then pound the customers accordingly? I sent pictures- got a declared value and repeatedly checked all the info and pay like $90 every 6 months. Hope i never need them but jeesh I told them over and over what I had. It must be the 1965 confusion. I work at a preferred shop that has to document everything to supplement crappy insurance estimates. What's preferred about that? The trust is one direction!

[Mike Marks]

After reading all of this I checked with my insurer, American Bankers Insurance Company who are USAA affiliates. My 2004 Backdraft has a Florida Title & Registration that says 1964 Cobra. Maxine Chatman, Maxine.C@americancollectors.com, explained to me that the date on the title and registration drives rates but usage by the individual matters even more. The Backdraft info is in my file and isn't material. I have a stated value policy of $45,500 and pay less than $500/yr.

Maxine is a real person and you get to real people instead of voicemail systems. They are actually enthusiasts and eager to speak with collectors. Her phone is 800-630-6302, extension 221.

I am sorry for the heartburn others have had but it helped me feel right about my situation.

CYA, Mike

[razerwire]

Stated value and agreed value are two different things, but I guess you know that.

[BDR0572]

I used Robin and Midwest ,had no issues, I pay a little under 5 for Insured Value of 53,500 any time i called or emailed Robin responded quickly to resolve any issues, had for about 3 years now .

[Mark IV]

FYI regarding the "Montana registration"
The Pitfalls Of The Montana License Plate Scam

[Quentin Z]

Robbin is Da Man! Bailed me out from the IDIOTS at Hagerty!

Robbin R. Terry, CIC
POB 229, 110 So 5th Street
Auburn, IL 62615
888.271.4000 (phone)
217.438.3347 (fax)
Office Hours 8:00-4:30 CST Mon-Fri
www.midwestclassicins.com

[Antny]

I'm in NY and use Condon & Skelly of NJ. Competitive rates. Been with them since 1983 continuously though, that might make a difference.

[1SwtRide]

Appreciate the follow up responses from everyone.

[Antny]

My 2001 Cobra (registered as a 2001 Custom, insured as a "Cobra Replica") is insured through Condon & Skelly (one of the companies on your list that you say you called and said no?). They are happy to insure any classic/vintage car or motorcycle for me, they have never said no. Anyway, my premium for this year is $425. Try them again, something doesn't sound right here.

[Malgyver]

This is an interesting thread.

I just called for insurance for my Hurricane Cobra I am just finishing building. I first got an online quote from Grundy. They quoted ~780 for the year, online estimate.

I called NCM, they ran my record and saw two small claims from the past couple years, both with payouts of about $2000. Both minor brushes with other cars in parking lots, but deemed my fault. They quoted me $11K for the year.

I called back Grundy, discussed the claims, and the rep called her underwriter, who said he had no issue with it, and the final quote from them was about $650.

The post is funny to me because after getting a 5 figure quote, anything in the 3 figures seems like a blessing.

[FredG]

I am in NJ. I pay $750 a year through Hagerty. I have Geico for my other vehicles. They wouldn't insure my 2014 Backdraft Cobra.

Fred

[Bird of prey]

I have State Farm. very pleased with the rate, and I have agreed value. I have my other cars and all my properties insured with them as well. that affects the rates. It’s registered as a 1965

[rubicon4me2]

Mine is registered as a 1965 Ford in AZ. It was inspected by ADOT and assigned a vin as a 1965 Ford. The insurance will only insure it as 1965 since that is what the title and registration says. I tried to tell them is was built in 2014 but they would only go by the title. I sent them photos when it was insured.

[twobjshelbys]

Originally Posted by rubicon4me2

Mine is registered as a 1965 Ford in AZ. It was inspected by ADOT and assigned a vin as a 1965 Ford. The insurance will only insure it as 1965 since that is what the title and registration says. I tried to tell them is was built in 2014 but they would only go by the title. I sent them photos when it was insured.

Most Cobra replica owners think what happened to you is a good thing.

[tims210]

I was shopping at a mall recently. When I went back to my car (my daily driver) I noticed that someone had scuffed my rear bumper backing in/out of the space next to me. Hit and run basically. My policy is with Allstate. I got a quote to repair it for $850. My deductible is $500. Obviously they will only cover $350 of it. Based on previous comments here, maybe I shouldn't claim it if it will affect my Cobra insurance rate through Midwest/American Modern?

[6t8stang]

Originally Posted by tims210

I was shopping at a mall recently. When I went back to my car (my daily driver) I noticed that someone had scuffed my rear bumper backing in/out of the space next to me. Hit and run basically. My policy is with Allstate. I got a quote to repair it for $850. My deductible is $500. Obviously they will only cover $350 of it. Based on previous comments here, maybe I shouldn't claim it if it will affect my Cobra insurance rate through Midwest/American Modern?

That is a no brainer non-report...

[twobjshelbys]

I raised my deductibles which saves premiums. We got caught in one of these a bunch of years ago on a homeowners claim. A windstorm blew something into our air conditioner and we put in a claim to replace it. The premiums went up way more than the cost of the entire unit had we replaced it ourselves. Same thing for our autos. I think I have 5K deductibles. Also don't believe this "accident forgiveness" BS. It may work on your carrier but if you change carriers you will still get dinged for the surcharge.

My wise old daddy told me when I was young and deciding what to do when I grow up that I should be a banker or an insurance company. Neither will (properly managed) lose money...